top of page
Version-1-Deep-Plum-and-Gold-600px.png
Clos de Tart bottles under portfolio review

The Fine Wine Portfolio Review Guide

A portfolio built five or ten years ago rarely still matches the one its owner intended. This guide sets out what an independent review of an existing fine wine portfolio should cover, what it should leave you with, and how we carry one out.

Trusted by

What a Review Should Cover

A review starts with the purpose of the portfolio rather than its value. Preservation, appreciation and a collection to pass on each call for a different shape of holding, so every position is judged against what the portfolio is meant to do and how long it is meant to be held. Without that, a strong return on one wine says very little about whether the whole is well built.

​

From there the review works through the evidence. It establishes exactly what is owned, where it is held and in whose name, then values each position against recent trades and live bids rather than an advertised price, because a quoted value and a realistic sale price are not always the same figure. It measures concentration by value as well as by label, since a portfolio of fifty wines can still rest on one region, one producer or one assumption about demand, and our article on the signs a portfolio is overexposed shows how that builds up unnoticed.

​

Provenance and liquidity complete the picture. A wine whose storage history cannot be documented is worth materially less to the next buyer, and a position with thin secondary demand may take longer to sell, or sell for less, than its valuation suggests. How to review an existing fine wine portfolio works through each of these checks in detail.

What a Review Should Leave You With

A good review ends in decisions rather than a valuation total. Each meaningful position should come out of it with a reason to be held, added to, reduced or prepared for sale, and the most useful test is whether you would buy the wine today, at today's price, if you did not already own it. Sometimes the right answer is to change very little, and the value of the review is knowing why.

​

The review should also look ahead to the exit. That means knowing who the likely buyer of each major position is, how readily it would sell and whether the portfolio holds enough liquid wines to give you choices if you need the capital. Our article on fine wine exit strategy covers how a sale is planned, and what a professional fine wine portfolio review should include follows one inherited collection through the whole process.

How We Carry Out a Review

We start with a private conversation about what you hold, why you hold it and what you want it to do, and then work from your inventory and storage records. You keep ownership and control of every wine throughout, and nothing is bought or sold on the strength of the review unless you decide it should be.

​

Because we hold no stock, a review is never a route to selling you our wines, and our view of what to keep, add or sell is shaped only by your portfolio. Every wine we buy for clients is bought at its documented cost, with our remuneration disclosed separately. The review is included under an Annual Mandate and charged as a set fee on On-Demand terms, and both are shown in full on How It Works.

​

Reviews suit investors who already hold fine wine, whether a portfolio bought through a merchant, a cellar assembled over many years or a collection inherited from a family member. If you are weighing a first allocation rather than reviewing an existing one, the Investor's Guide is a better place to start.

Further Reading on Reviewing a Portfolio

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a fine wine portfolio review?

An independent assessment of the wines you already own against what you want them to do. It covers valuation, concentration, provenance, storage, liquidity and exit, and ends with a recommendation for each meaningful position.

​

How is a review different from a valuation?

A valuation tells you what the wines might be worth today. A review asks whether the portfolio is still the right one to own, how much of that value could realistically be realised and what should happen next.

​

How often should a portfolio be reviewed?

There is no fixed timetable, because fine wine is a long-term holding. A review is most useful when a portfolio has grown materially, one region or producer has become a large share of it, your plans have changed or you are considering a sale.

​

What do I need to provide?

An inventory of what you hold, with purchase prices and dates where you have them, and details of where each wine is stored and in whose name. Gaps in the records are worth knowing about, so an incomplete inventory is a reason to start rather than to wait.

​

Will you recommend selling my wines through you?

We hold no stock and have no wines of our own to sell you. If the review concludes that a position should be sold, we explain the options and the costs so that you can decide.

​

What does a review cost?

The review is included under an Annual Mandate and charged as a set fee on On-Demand terms. Both are shown in full on How It Works.

Image by Kym Ellis

Find Out What Your Portfolio Is Doing

If you already hold fine wine and want an independent view of it, a private portfolio review is the simplest place to start. We will look at what you own and tell you honestly what we would hold, add, reduce or sell.

bottom of page